Wow, what a match-up between two epic tasting sandwiches. This was a tough comparison… its was like asking someone if they liked chocolate or rockyroad with caramel and sprinkles ice cream…how do you pick!?
Quick and dirty sandwich assessment:
Sandwich #1 (can’t remember name) was a great sandwich – cheap, very fresh, simple, but delicious. Definitely a sandwich I’d be happy to eat every day for lunch.
Sandwich #2 (#43 at Eleven City Diner) was also a great sandwich – flavorful, quality ingredients, complex, and filling. This is more of a “special occasion” sandwich because it’s amazing but unique, expensive, and definitely led to an afternoon food coma at work.
My pick: I have to go with sandwich #1. It was so fresh and seemed relatively healthy yet flavorful. It’s a simple sandwich but it definitely hit the spot without filling me up too much.